Chris Arnade Photography

Working Women

Twenty straight hours of walking the track for the men to see.

Twenty straight hours of dodging the police, jumping in garbage dumpsters if need be. “I stayed in there once for like two hours.”

Twenty hours and seven dates. “I made close to $300. First guy paid mad money, almost $100. Hotel date.”

Two guys wanted to go to the dumpsters. “Since the rains it’s muddy back there. I had to take off my heels and carry them.”

“I passed on like ten cars. If it don’t feel right I don’t do it. I been beat enough already.”

Twenty hours later, a rest.

A rest that includes two hits of crack and a few bags of heroin. “I don’t do drugs while working. If I make a bad decision on the streets it ends in death.”


Together

Both were raped by family members before they were ten.

Both escaped to the Bronx streets: Takeesha at eleven and Carmela at twelve.

Both started prostituting by thirteen. Carmela found men gave her things in exchange for her body. Takeesha’s mother sold her.

Both started injecting heroin into their bodies soon after.

Both have fought with addiction, the police, and men since.  

Both now have a habit that is close to $200 a day: Heroin to kill the sickness and crack to get a “little something.”

Takeesha still believes in love. “I did love Steve. He got an anger problem but I can be a crazy bitch.”

Carmela does not. “Love? There is no love out here. People only want what they can get from you.”

Both are now together.  “We stayed up the first night talking and talking. We both like, “wow this person really understands what I have been through, understands I ain’t just trash.’  We watch each other’s back. Right girl?”


More on addiction here: Faces of Addiction


Farewell Letter to Millie

image

Millie was buried in a 70’ x 20’ x 6’ trench on Hart Island in late May.

Used since the 1860’s as the city cemetery, the island contains the remains of close to one million people, none with markers or gravestones.

The island, run by the Department of Correction, can be visited on the third Thursday of each month after placing your name on a list.

After a short ferry ride from City Island, visitors are escorted to a small fenced plot with a ceremonial tombstone and three benches.

I visited this morning and brought a note Shelly (Michael) had given me to read on the island.

For you
For you I pray you are finally happy, at peace, and full of joy.
I know you are in a better place then here where we are stuck till our last day. I miss you my friend and love you always. I’m kind of jealous but mad you are gone. You will never be forgotten.
I love you Millie

Shelly


Read more about Millie’s death here: The Death of Yafna Garcia

More about Hart Island here: Hart Island Project


Perspective

image

The apartment was dark, loud, and filled with smoke. Pots of water boiling on the stove for a bath filled the back with steam.

A few women clustered around a crack pipe. Two men waited outside a bedroom for their turn with a girl inside. Other men lounged on the couch waiting for texts to tell them where to deliver next.

Various makeshift locks held the door to the hallway tight: A screwdriver as a bolt, a triangle of wood as a wedge, and an old dog leash as a chain.

Takeesha and Carmela came out of their room. Carmela was barely dressed with just an old dirty sheet to cover her body. Takeesha was dope sick and crying.

They both eyed me. Takeesha spoke, “You ok, Chris? You looked tired.”

“I am ok, just lots of stuff going on.”

Takeesha came over and hugged me. “Honey you know you can talk to us anytime. We here for you. Don’t be afraid, nothing is really ever that bad.”

More on addiction here: Faces of Addiction


Twenty minutes on a Tuesday afternoon

image

The police Mobile Command Center returned to Hunts Point Avenue Tuesday morning. The shooting early Monday evening, a teenager shot at five times and hit twice, was probably responsible.

Officers lounged around gossiping. One chomped on his cigar, “We could only get away for one day before bullets started flying.”

Four police cars were clustered around the Tub & Tumble: Somebody had kicked and broken the glass door.

Ten minutes later three police cars pulled onto the sidewalk at the corner deli. Two teens waiting outside were backed against the wall. “I ain’t do nothing. I just waiting for my sandwich. What you stopping me for?”

“We don’t have to give you a reason. Shooting is a reason enough.”

“I ain’t shoot nobody. Damn.”

Kids zoom by on their scooters. Pepsi, out to buy a cig, shakes her ass at the police.

The teen is trying to maintain his cool, “What you gonna charge me with?”

The young cop, hair spiked with gel, waves his finger an inch from the taller teen’s face, “What you want to be charged with. I can write you up for whatever.”

It is a beautiful spring day, a bit windy but the perfect temperature. I look around. I spot ten dealers and about twenty heavy crack users all watching.

The spiky-haired cop continues to argue with the taller teen. Both of their pants are slung low around their waists. One pulled lower by the weight of his belt the other by choice.

Takeesha looks over before jumping into a John’s car. They watch the argument while she pulls out a pipe. They smoke some crack, laugh, and drive away.

The officer relents, his hair further mussed from the fight. Delivery trucks waiting for parking replace the cop cars.

The teens grab their sandwiches inside,  “Fuck them. If I shoot somebody they will know. I won’t be leaving a living body for the ambulance. I will do it right.”


Walk from my neighborhood of Brooklyn Heights to Red Hook and back. I do it four times a week. Today I brought my camera.


My walk along the spine of Queens (click on top picture to view & read)

From the Queensboro bridge to Flushing along Queens blvd and Roosevelt ave under the 7 train.

Queens is by far my favorite New York borough. It is one of the most diverse places in the world filled with folks united in desire to find a better life.

If you have never been then go. Walk underneath the 7 train. It is my favorite joy in this city.


Carmela

imageDay one

Carmela was in bed nude and high. A john had just left.  Filled with heroin her eyes were lolling with her head.  Between nods she spoke.

“I ran away when I was 12. I was in five different homes, or maybe seven, I got tired of being molested. It started when I was six.”

“I started with heroin, alcohol, and weed.”

“When did I start prostituting? I always have. I mean I always thought you had to give up your body for food or to find a place to sleep. I never knew it had a fancy name like prostitution till I was like 16. I just knew it as the way a girl lived on the streets.”

“Men come here. They buy me drugs. I do as much as I can. Heroin cause I like to forget and crack to wake me up.”

“I was clean for about two years. I went looking for my birth parents. My mom died from drugs when I would of been ten. My dad. Nobody knows who that man was.”

She grabbed a crack pipe and pulled in the smoke.

I asked if I could take her picture. She nodded and positioned herself in a pornographic pose. I asked her if we could do a straight shot. “I got no shame in my game.”

imageDay two

Carmela was dressed with her hair freshly washed. She asked to see the pictures from yesterday.

On a tiny phone with a cracked screen we searched for my webpage. The search ended with a call from a John.

She shot heroin into her and sat on the bed. She wanted to speak.

“I am more than just a naked prostitute who smokes crack. I may seem comfortable being that but I am not.”

“I hate what I do. I feel guilty and embarrassed by being out here hustling. I get clean and somehow I keep coming back. It’s the only thing I know the only place I have power.”

“Just today I was walking down the street. This nine-year old boy kicking a ball started following me. I turned and he turned. He was following me because I was for sale. I felt awful. Would I want my boy following a prostitute around?”

“Then two hour later I was crossing streets with food from the bodega. These two elderly women were watching me. One said to the other, ‘She ought to be ashamed of herself.’ I was.”

“You know what I have always wanted to be? A square. That kid who did everything right and had parents who hugged them and told them how much they loved them.”

“Love? There is no love out here. People only want what they can get from you then they throw you away. I stopped trying to find love.”

“Here is a poem I wrote. Will you please post it?”


            Don’t worry.

            Don’t worry if you hear me cry,

            I am just letting out the frustration inside.

            Don’t worry if you hear me yell, “Go to hell”           

            I am just tired of him saying you better not tell.

            Don’t worry if I seem tired and weak,

            Its just my soles are worn from hustling in these streets.

            Don’t worry about me,

            Because I am a survivor,

            I’ll always eat.

 More on addiction here: Faces of addiction

 


An hour amongst addicts

image

“Sam is on the run. She stole $1,500 and a bundle from some dealers. They gave a local kid $500 to kill her. “

“We need you to try this shit. Just got it shipped in. I hear it is righteous.”

“Damn man he is FUUUUUUUUCKED UP. This shit is for real.”

“ You like my ass? I got the best booty in the Bronx.”

“She says she has leukemia. I think she just wants attention but her phone full of messages from hospital about treatment. Doesn’t matter either way. Crack is her treatment. “

“Keep the curtain closed, please. I can’t be seen. They can see up here you know. Now they got glasses that can even see through curtains. Google stuff.”

“I was clean for six years. Now I been here for two weeks. Smoking. I spent those six years thinking about this moment. Craving.”

image

“I got no good veins left. E used to shoot me in places I couldn’t reach but he is in jail. I got to shoot myself in my abscesses.”

“Peanut got thrown in jail. He was with his girl, Rosy. Deal went wrong. They jumped out of the second floor window. He hurt his knee. Police got him. She ran a few blocks. Dealers tracked her down and broke a cane over her head.”

“I got thrown out of the shelter because of my nephew. When I was gone he beat up some guy on the lower floor. I was gone and I got blamed.”

“Police gave all of us summons for open containers. Nice guy. White. He could of dragged us in but he knows us. Knows we harmless. It’s funny cause I don’t even drink or like beer. You know that. I am about the pipe and needle.”

“My son? He angry cause I told him his dad died of the virus. He can’t deal with that. His father never told him while he was alive. He was a good man. Just had the virus.”

“Greg is the king of Hunts Point. Eighty-six-year-old crack head.”

“She is lucky. She got the virus. That’s an apartment and a check.”


image

 


Addiction Trumps All

Tiffany asked me for a cigarette. I paused. She was eight months pregnant.

She was leaning against the monastery wall waiting for johns to pay her for sex so she could buy more crack.

The need for crack, methadone, and cigarettes was everything.

I declined, “I only got white boy cigarettes, you know, Marlboro.”

She smiled and in her strong southern voice said, “That’s ok. Its better I don’t.”

Since I last saw Tiffany a week ago, prostituting at 2:00 am with her belly filled with baby, I have not stopped thinking.

I know her story: Sex work starting at 12, Crack and heroin at 14, HIV at 19, a father who beat her mother, both parents drug addicts.

I continually see female addicts abuse their body while pregnant and male addicts run from being fathers to children.

Addiction truly trumps all.


Political Rant: Comparing Apples and Oranges

image(Prince with “How to Spend it” from FT)

Before spending the last two years photographing and writing about Hunts Point, New York’s poorest neighborhood, I worked on Wall Street for twenty years.

I get asked often, “What have you learned from those two different experiences?”

My one line answer?

“When you’re wealthy you make mistakes. When you are poor you go to jail.”

Roughly a third of the people in Hunts Point I started following two years ago are in jail, facing long sentences for non-violent possession charges.

Those on Wall Street who were the most responsible for the financial crisis (none of my friends mind you!) were compensated best and never have to work again.

Yes it is a bit like comparing apples and oranges. That is the point though. We have built two very different societies with two very different sets of values.

Poverty is all-encompassing friction that retards most movement. It has many mothers: Inferior schools, sparse jobs, lack of information, pollution, etc.  It feeds on itself.

Leaving poverty is close to impossible. It requires overcoming enormous odds and headwinds.

Some do it and we hold them as examples so we can ignore the rest that can’t.

We then say. Look we have a fair society.


The Death of Yafna Garcia

image

The last picture I have of Millie is of her talking to a stray cat.

It was a late October night. She was working “the spot,” a shuttered loading dock on an industrial street where I had first met her over a year before. Always shy, this night she was quieter than usual. She spoke to the ground, her voice a soft mumble of English and Spanish, a tight smile on her face. Always fashionable, she was dressed as if headed for a nightclub with small iron-on stars running the length of her pant seam.

We made small talk before she asked for a favor. Could I drive her to her mother’s place? She was tired and cold. Her body was sore from withdrawal. She hadn’t been scoring much.

Before she got into the car she bent over and whispered to the dirty cat. What she said, I don’t know.

Another prostitute had previously spoken to the cat, “You a good boy. We ain’t that different really, out here with nobody to care for us. We get by though.”

Millie’s body language said the same, although she would never voice it. She was not one for talking about herself or ever wanting pity.

Before leaving Hunts Point she asked to stop by 13-14, the notorious drug building, to buy methadone. I declined, citing time.  We drove five miles away, to a small nursing home in the shadow of the Cross Bronx. Millie disappeared inside, unsure if her mother would accept her.

That was the last I ever saw of her.

Millie was seen in Hunts Point two months later in the local Laundromat, just before Christmas. Ana, as she has for over five years, opened the bathroom of the Tub and Tumble so Millie could clean up.  Mille soon fell asleep in one of chairs next to the spinning dryers. Awoken, Millie asked Ana to call an ambulance.

She was taken to Lincoln Hospital, where she died on the night of January 6.

Yafna Garcia aged 41: The 97th death in the Bronx in 2013.

image

The hospital, having no information on her family, moved her body to the morgue, where she laid unclaimed as #97.

Unclaimed by her birth mother who still might be in their native Puerto Rico, or maybe in the Bronx.

Unclaimed by the mother in the Bronx nursing home, the one who raised her after her birth mother fell into the haze of drugs.

Unclaimed by a man who had lived with her birth mother and died of HIV. Maybe that was her father. There were so many men who spent so little time.

Unclaimed by one of the thirteen sisters or brothers who share a mother, but rarely a father, or were raised in the same house.

Unclaimed by her street husband, “Pooty,” the father of two or three of her children, who is now in a Franklin Correctional Facility near the Canadian border serving the end of a two-year sentence for criminal possession of a controlled substance.

Unclaimed by any of her four children, the oldest nineteen, the youngest just one, all in foster homes after being taken from her sisters.

Unclaimed by any of the other addicts of Hunts Point. Her “sisters, aunts, brothers, uncles, and mothers.” They were all busy scrambling for enough money to buy their daily dose of drugs. They couldn’t look for her anyway; few had homes much less computers or phones. Rumors were their internet.

image

Millie’s initial absence barely registered on the streets of Hunts Point. She often disappeared for weeks. Months passed and rumors started to fill the void. They wrapped around the obvious candidate: The massive abscess that covered her left forearm. The one she hid beneath a bandana. An infection that started from shooting up and grew with picking. “She died from an amputation gone wrong.” No, “She died from infection from maggots.” 

By March, one of the thirteen siblings, an older sister, appeared at the Tub & Tumble looking to raise money for a funeral.  She had learned of the death after looking for Millie in the public hospitals, something she did every now and again.

A different sister, this one younger, showed up two weeks later also looking to raise money and trying to piece together exactly what had happened.  They both needed legal proof of their kinship to get her body.

The body, however, was no longer at the hospital. Sometime in the middle of January it had been shipped to the City Medical Examiner’s office for autopsy and holding, as all unclaimed bodies in New York are.

Case #97 of the Bronx Medical Examiner. Cause of Death: Bacterial Endocarditis of tricuspid valve due to intravenous drug abuse. 

This information had not made it back to either Millie’s family or friends. In early April they still continued to talk of raising money for a funeral. That was not going to happen. Millie was already buried.

On March 21, Millie’s body was shipped from the Office of the Chief  Medical Examiner to City Cemetery on Hart Island.

Inmates from Rikers Island placed her body in a wooden box made by other inmates. She was placed in a massive trench (70’ x 20’ x 6’) joining roughly one million others that lay beneath an empty field on a small island two miles from the shores of the Bronx.

Many of her siblings do not know she is dead. Those who do know don’t realize they cannot bury Millie on their terms. It is unlikely they will ever be able to pay their last respects. Hart Island is run by the Department of Correction and clouded in security and secrecy. It is close to impossible to visit. Family, after showing many documents, can fill out paperwork and hope. If they are accepted they can only get to the island via a ferry that leaves once a month. Her grave is unmarked: They wouldn’t be able to find it, anyway.

image

I started to tell her friends on the streets.

“What? I thought she died of maggots?” I tried to read a note from a doctor friend of mine, “Skin bacteria gets introduced via injection into arm veins and are carried back to the heart. They stick on the tricuspid valve (endocarditis). The bacteria on the valve then grow into a clot and subsequently shower the rest of the body, brain, kidneys, lungs, and joints.“

In the end I said, “Her heart caught the same infection that was on her arm.”

Pepsi cried, not just for the death, but because, “they buried her like a stray dog. I hope to God and pray that I don’t get treated like that. Please, I want the decency to be buried by those who love me.”

Another talked of the constant fear of ending up like Millie, buried in Hart Island. “I had gotten ten bags of great shit. I knew it was all going in me and that it could end that night. So I wrote my father’s phone number in marker on my stomach before shooting up for the paramedics to see.”

Michael cried, cleared his eyes, and looked at me. “Honestly? I know she is in a much better place than we are.”

Everybody fears telling her husband, if he ever comes back after prison. He was with Millie the January night just over a year ago when she injected herself with heroin and crack after six months of being clean. She was seven months pregnant and within one hour she was in labor. The child, her last, was born premature and is now with the state.

The sisters, the ones who know, are still hoping for a funeral. Hoping to get the death certificate and perhaps custody of the two younger children. They miss her. “She was my older sister and raised me. When she moved from Puerto Rico to the Bronx at nineteen I had nobody. When I came to the Bronx she had this awful addiction but she still was the only one I could ever go to. She often had nothing. Nothing, but she managed to help me and give to me.”

image

Last summer Millie was working her usual spot on a Sunday afternoon. She was sitting with Mary Alice on the ledge of the loading dock. They were telling stories of what the men who paid them wanted, laughing at the absurd requests.

I asked Millie and Mary Alice what they wanted. Mary Alice worked through a dream of rehabilitation and redemption.

Millie was her usual quiet, shy self. I had to prod her to answer the question. She smiled, “I want my kids back. I know it probably won’t happen. Still, if I get them back it means I will be clean and I hope that happens. I am tired of this life. Tired. You can only do this so long. We say it doesn’t hurt. It does.”

She looked down, picking at her bright green leggings. She lifted her head and with a big smile said, “Oh and also one of them chocolate-dipped cones from McDonald’s. I love them. You can turn them upside down and they don’t drip.”

image

More on addiction and Hunts Point: Faces of Addiction

 


My walk from the northern tip of Manhattan to the southern tip. A 13-mile trip. Click on upper picture to start slideshow.


I ain’t a shooter

image

Brenda screamed as Michael jammed in the needle.

Heroin this way was new to her. For thirty years she has smoked or sniffed or swallowed her drugs, never injected them.

She was proud of this. It is what made her different, “My addiction is bad but I ain’t a shooter.”

She has always been the voice of reason amidst the chaos. She holds things together enough to cook meals and wash clothes.  She doesn’t let shit happen to her. It’s why she stabbed an abusive husband.

Two weeks ago she was convinced to shoot heroin. She loved the immediate rush. She now spends all her time at Michael’s house. She is back to working the streets. She hasn’t cooked since.

She still can’t jam a needle into herself. Michael does that. Five seconds later she is unable to speak, hardly able to move, head frozen.


image


She tries to smoke crack but can’t. The movements are too hard.

Michael looks at her, “Brenda. We got to get out of this. We got to go to rehab.”

Brenda stares ahead unhearing and unmoving.

image


Destiny Sanchez

image

Fifteen-year-old Destiny Sanchez was found dead the morning following Thanksgiving, her body covered in bleach.

She had been strangled and possibly raped. She was found in the inner landing of a building where her father’s girlfriend’s sister lived.

The media descended on Hunts Point. The story was carried in some European papers.

image

A memorial of candles, flowers, and stuffed animals sprung up in front of the building where she died.

A candlelight vigil and march through the neighborhood attracted close to two hundred people. 

Rumors swirled around Hunts Point the following weeks. Her father, a local hothead, had fought with his girlfriend’s brother and was in jail the night of the murder.

image

Police soon arrested that brother, Luis Vega, who stayed sometimes in the building where the body was found. He was seen on video cameras buying Destiny liquor Thanksgiving night at “Hero’s Corner.”  Others saw her with friends that night hanging out.

He was charged with endangering the welfare of a child (a misdemeanor). He is still in Rikers on $1 bail. His next court date is April 30.

No other charges have followed. No new media stories have been written.

The memorial was cleared away in January. The new residents of the building found it spooky.

A blood splatter a block away, rumored to be from Destiny, is all that is left to remind the neighborhood.

image

Picture of Destiny Sanchez is from her Facebook page.